The peer review method that my group used was talking about the problems we thought was wrong with our paper. Then we all read each other paper and answered the questions on the review paper. I believed it worked well because we identified our own errors first then we were told what else could be fixed in the paper. I feel like I received some very insightful information for my paper. Maybe I could conjure up a new idea for my paper. It also gave me new ideas about what I can do to improve my paper and what I can add to enhance the paper. All of theses suggestions worked well with the peer review. I really can not think of anything that did not work in the peer review process. I believe it went very well. Something I would do differently is change the way we went about our review process. There was nothing wrong with the way we did it but trying many different ways may be more effective than the method that we used today. I think peer review is a wonderful way t better your paper besides being lazy and not really wanting to do it, it is very helpful.
Monday, February 4, 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
Since you were in my group, I agree with your blog. I think the method that we used was effective, and made it easier for us to edit because we identified our own problems. I also think that we could have done several different methods to review our paper. Being in your group made it easier for me to peer edit, due to the method that we chose.
I also found the peer reviews to be very helpful,(although you were not in my group). The people in my group basically did the same thing your group did. We filled out the questions that were handed out in the beginning of class, read each others papers, and gave information to one another as of how to improve each ones papers. I came out of my group with a clear idea as to what I was suppose to be writing about and whether or not I was connecting with my audience. The only thing I regret about peer review is not doing another one to ensure that I got all the errors out of my paper, (but hey I guess that's what the writing studio is for).
Post a Comment